Profile
An absolutely first-rate public lawyer whose advocacy is very effective indeed.
Chambers UK
“Delightful to deal with … really, really smart and wonderful.” Chambers & Partners
“She is instructed in all the major inquests and inquiries – she is outstanding.” Legal 500
“At the top of her game.” Legal 500
“She is very hard-working and good at getting into the detail of a case.” Chambers & Partners
“She is fantastic, has a lovely manner and is really good in court. Judges love her.” Chambers & Partners
“Phenomenally hard working.” “A real attention to detail.” “She is completely and utterly dependable, and absolutely brilliant.” Chambers & Partners
“She has a really effective manner. She’s very relaxed, very conscientious and the judges trust her.“ Chambers & Partners
“A highly rated junior barrister who offers expertise and experience in terrorism-related cases amongst others…”Chambers & Partners
Melanie Cumberland is a leading junior with a broad range of practice areas, including crime, extradition, confiscation, mutual legal assistance, administrative law, public inquiries and inquests.
Melanie has extensive experience appearing in the higher courts, in cases before the Supreme Court, Court of Appeal and High Court. She also regularly acts on behalf of individuals and the Government in cases before the European Court of Human Rights.
She has been instructed in some of the most complex and sensitive criminal and quasi-criminal cases of recent years, including a challenge to the refusal to issue arrest warrants against Tony Blair, Jack Straw and Lord Goldsmith for their participation in the Iraq War (R (on the application of Al-Rabbat) v. Westminster Magistrates’ Court); Supreme Court appeals concerning a challenge to search warrants issued in reliance on sensitive material (R (on the application of Haralambous) v. St Albans Crown Court); and sentences of imprisonment for public protection based on their alleged breach of the principle of lex mitior (R v. Docherty).
Melanie was first appointed by the Attorney General as junior counsel to the Crown in 2009, and has been on the A Panel since 2016. She undertakes a range of high profile work for a variety of government departments and has particular expertise in national security work, inquests, public inquiries and judicial review proceedings raising issues of principle under the criminal law.
She has acted in many of the most important public inquiries and inquests of recent years including the Westminster Bridge Inquests, the Litvinenko Inquiry, the inquest into the death of Alexander Perepilichnyy and the Al Sweady Inquiry. She has also been instructed in a number of judicial review and civil damages claims arising from the Government’s military involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan; for example, in claims brought by Rahmatullah, Al-Sweady and Al-Saadoon, and in appeals before the Court of Appeal and Supreme Court, arising from those claims.
Expertise
- Member of the Attorney General’s Civil Panel of Counsel (A Panel).
- Sunley Scholar of the Honourable Society of Lincoln’s Inn.
- MA (Hons) Modern Languages (French and Spanish), Oxford University.
- Bilingual in Spanish
- Fluent in French.
To view Melanie Cumberland’s Privacy Notice, please click here.
Recognition
Notable cases
Spain v Gogeaskoetxea Arronategui
An alleged plot by members of ETA to kill the King of Spain, as well as the murder of a police officer and the causing of terrorist...
Government of the United States of America v Abid Naseer
An alleged Al-Qaeda plot to cause explosions in Manchester City Centre in 2009.
Government of the United States of America v Tesler and Chodan
Foreign bribery on a massive scale, relating to the procurement of a liquefied natural gas contract in Bonny Island, Nigeria.
Murua v Central Court of Criminal Proceedings, Madrid, Spain
Alleged membership of the terrorist organisation ETA, and involvement in several terrorist attacks in the Basque country.
Azevedo v Criminal Court of Lisbon, Portugal
Leading Counsel in the extradition proceedings of Joao Antonio Vale e Azevedo, the former President of the Benfica Club in Portugal.
Spain v Jamil Al Banna and Omar Deghayes
Al Banna and Deghayes were arrested upon their arrival in the United Kingdom from Guantanamo Bay, on European Arrest Warrants issued for...
Germany v Gerald Toben
Concerning offences of Holocaust denial.
HM Attorney General v MGN and NGN
Contempt of court proceedings relating to reporting of the arrest of Christopher Jefferies on suspicion of involvement in the death of...
The Al-Sweady Public Inquiry
Instructed as Junior for the Ministry of Defence.
Human rights challenge to Part 4 of the Counter-Terrorism Act 2008
Junior to First Treasury Counsel on behalf of the Secretary of State for the Home Department.
R (Sanaa Al-Jaf (“Um Haider”) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs
Junior for the Foreign and Commonwealth Office in judicial review proceedings concerning allegations of sexual harassment and assault of...
Strasbourg Cases
Instructed by the Foreign and Commonwealth Office in three cases before the European Court of Human Rights concerning the rights of a child...